Tuesday, 13 May 2014

Revisiting Doctor Who – Series 2, Episode 10 – Love & Monsters

Revisiting Doctor Who – Series 2, Episode 10 – Love & Monsters

Marc Warren runs up a hill, and comes across the TARDIS. There’s some paper rolling across the ground in front of him like tumbleweed, which is symbolic of this episode as a whole. Marc hears The Doctor and Rose shouting and goes to investigate. He opens a door and some beast roars at him. It cuts to him making a Vlog, and he wants to tell us the rest of his story.
Cue title sequence…
The Doctor appears behind the beast, tempting him with meat while Rose throws the wrong colour bucket of water over him. There’s some chasing from one side of some rooms to the other, which was funny in one cartoon when I was three, but now? Seriously? I know this is a kid’s show, but seriously?
Marc does some filming of his home. He’s a great actor, but already this is rubbish. Or is it just that I’ve already seen it and know it’s rubbish? Apparently he saw a disapproving looking Doctor when he was young. Marc’s name is actually Elton. He was there when the Auton’s caused hell in Rose. He saw the space ship crash in World War III (or whatever part 1 of that arc was). He saw the Racknos, he met Jackie Tyler, he did a bunch of things. Actually, this bit isn’t so bad because it’s basically just Marc Warren. Though at the same time, he’s now just dancing and what the hell has that got to do with the plot? Oh, right; ‘filler’. His computer once blew up because the internet was being used a lot (I get that this is supposed to be ‘funny’, but meh). He met Ursula who runs a blog about The Doctor. She’s part of an inner sanctum, studying the Time Lord, and something bad is going to happen to her, something ridiculously stupid. Oh look! It’s Michael from Alan Partridge in their special group! There are other people I recognise, but they aren’t Michael so I won't name them. Also I've already forgotten their names. They call themselves LINDA, which stands for something.
They do readings, group therapy, form a band. Though this is dull as sin, at least Peter Kay hasn’t arrived ye- Oh look, there he is. Believe it or not, the episode goes downhill from here.
Peter Kay is dressed like a pimp, which would probably make for a more exciting episode. They do some talking or something, I don’t know. It’s hard to hear over the sound of my inner-fan dying. ‘Bliss’, which is a stupid name, stays behind to talk to ‘Mr Kennedy’, which is an alter ego of Peter Kay. She screams, so maybe she heard about the plot for this episode.
Mr Kennedy has taken over the group, without any protest, which is stupid. I know these are underground conspiracy-type people, who are likely to straight away cede leadership of a group to someone they've only just met, but this is just stupid.
Gods, what’s happening now? Peter Kay doesn’t like being touched, apparently. I don’t want to know any more about that.
They’re hunting Rose and The Doctor at the moment. Ha, actually it was pretty funny when Marc Warren though it’d take ages to find Rose and a lady pointed out her exact address straight immed-Oh, he’s dancing again. Great. He deliberately bumps into Jackie in a launderette. I do like Jackie. She’s already made this episode eighty-three times better. ‘The Adventures of Jackie Tyler’. That would be awesome. She melts my heart with her smile. Why does she have trouble finding a man? She’s lovely, with beautiful eyes. Quite domineering, but then I quite like that I’m getting off track a bit.
Where was I? Oh yeah, this episode sucks. And written by Russell T Davies! How?! He’s a fantastic writer! I don’t care if his cliffhanger resolutions aren’t always brilliant, he’s one of Who’s greatest assets in the…Russell T Davies era.
There’s a love plot or two going on here. Sweet Marc Warren, not realising that Jackie is deliberately finding jobs to keep him arou-Christ that’s a short skirt, Jackie. Yep, Jackie and her seduction attempts are easily the best thing in this episode. I could watch this all day. Ha, the way she pours the wine all over him! Repeatedly! Seriously, that bit is classic. I mean, don’t sit through all of this episode just for that one bit; just look it up on YouTube.
Jackie then gets morose when Rose rings, but Marc Warren gets pizza. Is this episode meant to show what happens to those left behind? Oh gods, he’s dancing again. STOP DANCING MARC, PLEASE! I WANT MY SCIENCE FICTION DRAMA BACK! Oh, here’s a bit of drama. Jackie discovers Marc just wants The Doctor. And look, she mentioned being left behind! I was right! Woo! I don’t know why I’m celebrating. I think perhaps with this episode, you need to take anything you can.
The group are arguing blah blah blah. Yeah, screw you Kennedy, we’re off for a Chinese takeaway. I’d love a Chinese right now. It’s lunchtime and I’m hungry. I DO have a delicious Beef Wellington that my wife made, so I’ll just have to enjoy that instead. I’ll enjoy it a lot more than the rest of this episode, anyway. Oh, Michael’s about to get done in by Kennedy. Marc and the other one head back inside, to find Kennedy hiding behind a newspaper. They hear Michael calling for help, and find that Kennedy has transformed into something that isn’t Peter Kay. He absorbs his victims, which just comes across as overly strange, both visually and whatever the opposite of visually is. An ‘Abzorbaloff’, so he is named. He absorbs Marc’s girlfriend too. Well, I preferred Jackie, anyway. Peter Kay looks like he’s having a poo, which is just bizarre. Also, the award for ‘Best Stating of the Bleeding Obvious’ goes to his girlfriend, who says, quite seriously, that she can read the Abzorbaloff’s thoughts and that Marc Warren is next. No. Freakin’. Way. Peter Kay is chasing him in his underpants, which is not a sentence I will ever type in a positive way.
Thank the gods, The Doctor is here at last. And Rose is annoyed with Marc for upsetting Jackie. Blah blah blah blah blah blah blah absorbing blah blah blah blah Doctor uses reverse psychology blah blah blah blah the absorbed people try to pull Peter Kay apart while Marc destroys his cane, melting him. Then the most ridiculously ridiculous thing of all happens, as the absorbed people become paving stones, and Marc has the strangest relationship with his girlfriend that the world has ever seen.
The Doctor reveals that when Marc saw him years ago, he’d been investigating a beast in the shadows, but he couldn’t stop it killing Marc’s mum. This part is actually really tragic. Like, SERIOUSLY tragic. I get really upset nowadays about that sort of thing. Doesn’t make it a worse episode, but you hope for an ending to cheer you up and well, that ain’t happening.
There’s a quick montage of the group, as Marc talks about people paying the price for knowing The Doctor. It’s also revealed that it’s The Doctor’s fault that Marc’s girlfriend has been turned into a paving stone, as he did some reversal thingy that-OH THANK GOD IT’S FINISHED!
You might have guessed that I’m not a fan of this episode. I know that fans of cult television are prone to going over the top, and I’m fully willing to accept that children will probably really enjoy this episode (and, if I’m honest, it’s clearly just trying to be harmless fun) but I just find it terrible from start to finish. Doctor-lite episodes can be phenomenal (Blink and Turn Left are two of the best episodes ever), but this is appalling. The constant wasting of screentime with Marc Warren dancing? What the hell does that have to do with Doctor Who? It doesn’t make me warm to the character any better. Marc Warren is one of my favourite British actors, and if nothing else he’s very good in the role here, it’s just that the role is terrible.
The only bits that are any good are the bits with Jackie Tyler. It really is genuinely hilarious when she tries to seduce him, particularly where she repeatedly throws wine over him. One of the funniest moments Who has ever produced, in my opinion. There’s also meant to be a genuine attempt to have us think about how life with The Doctor affects those left behind, but we’ve seen that done far better with Mickey. He was with Rose and The Doctor for a large part of the series so far, yet left behind at the same time, and we have every sympathy for him because of it. In this episode I just don’t care. Well, I feel sorry for Jackie and all, but I don’t go away thinking about how awful it is for those left behind. I just wish the episode would hurry up and finish.
Ursula will never age apparently, though she doesn’t see the problem with this. She doesn’t see the problem with spending the rest of eternity as a paving slab, who will see Elton (and any love after it) die. There is literally no way this would not drive someone insane after about five minutes. I know this episode is plainly designed for younger children, but it’s horrific on so many levels (not just it’s quality). Also, Elton and Ursula apparently have a bit of a love life. I really think he gets the better end of the stick there.
Seriously, if you wanted to put someone off Doctor Who for life, this is how to do it. I know this was designed by a child for Blue Peter, and my conscience is racked with guilt for criticising it, but there are so many ways that they could have told a better story. That's the bigger problem than the monster itself. True, I can’t think of any, but there simply must be, because there can’t be anything worse than this. And from Russell The Davies, too! Perhaps it's also the fact that a 9-year old boys idea of a monster isn't necessarily something that is going to work well on screen, in a television story. That's no fault of the child, but a fault of the producers either committing to feature the winner in the episode, or picking a creature that wouldn't translate well. 
Torchwood Mentions
Victor Kennedy notes that the Bad Wolf Virus erased all mention of Rose Tyler from the Torchwood files on The Doctor (nice mention of Bad Wolf there!).
Harold Saxon Mentions
Our first airing of the name Harold Saxon, as a poll mentions him in the newspaper that the Abzorbaloff is reading.
Overall
Whilst children might find this brilliant, anyone else will likely find this to be the worst episode of Doctor Who ever created. The comedy isn’t funny, the characters aren’t likeable, and the villain just doesn’t work. Besides one genuinely hilarious scene involving Jackie Tyler (though when isn’t there a genuinely hilarious scene involving Jackie Tyler?), I can’t find a single thing to recommend about it.
1/10

Sunday, 11 May 2014

Revisiting Doctor Who - Series 2, Episode 9 - The Satan Pit

Revisiting Doctor Who - Series 2, Episode 9 - The Satan Pit

Last week...SATAN APPEARED!

Cue title sequence...

The crew open fire on the Ood as the ship goes back into orbit. One more of the crew that I swear has only just been added gets killed, as Captain Zach narrowly escapes, and they agree to enact Strategy 9. The Doctor makes contact, telling them that the pit is open, but there's no sign of the Beast. Scott ignores Zach's orders to return to the base, but The Doctor advises retreat for once. Shit must be about to get real if he wants to go home.

Strategy 9 is to open the airlocks with the crew inside the main control centre, jettisoning the Ood. Before any of it can happen though, the Beast, or at least the Beast talking through the Ood as 'The Legion', tells them all that this is his domain and that they'll die. Apparently, some people of the Light chained him 'before time', so he's a bit pissed off. He taunts them all, before flashing an image of a Balrog on screen again. The Doctor tries to keep them calm, playing them up against the Beast playing their fears. In the middle of this, the cable holding the lift breaks, stranding The Doctor and Scott at the bottom, with only 55 minutes of air left. 

The Ood begin to break through door bolts. To buy them time and find an escape route, Zach reroutes power from the rockets. On the base, Danny realises that if he can flip some monitor and transmit a flare it'll disrupt the telepathic link, but they need to go to Ood Habitat to do that. Zach will have to manually send air along with them as they go. They all drop into a ventilation shaft to begin their journey as the Ood break into the room behind them. After a short while they pause while they wait for more air, when the Ood appear at the end of the shaft, scuttling quickly towards them. They flee as quick as they can with the Ood in hot pursuit, Jeffersen staying behind to buy them some time, ending up trapped on the wrong side of a locked door. The other reach the final door, but when it opens there are Ood there waiting. As Zach tries to get that door shut again, the crew flee, escaping upwards as they-WAIT! OMG! TOBY IS STILL EVIL! HE HAD RED EYES AND TOLD THE OOD TO WAIT! OMG! WHAT A MEAN PERSON! Anyway, Danny gets the signal sent out, and the Ood collapse. 

Down below, Scott makes plans to use the broken cable to abseil into the pit, but The Doctor insists that he should be the one to go down. He waxes lyrical about beasts and myths to Scott as he goes, until they run out of cable. He knows that he has no choice but to jump, and he needs to take that leap of faith. Gods, that's a big drop - he just keeps going into the darkness until he's disappeared. As Rose makes contact again, Scott tells her that he mentioned her before the end. Zach tells her that there's no way they can save her, and they have to leave her down there. Though Scott agrees, Rose refuses to leave The Doctor, so she has to be restrained. They head for the rocket, noticing that the Ood are beginning to wake, as the telepathic field begins to re-establish itself. Rose wakes as the rocket leaves base, pointing the gun at Zach, but he knows she can't go through with it. 

Many miles down in the pit, The Doctor has survived with nothing more than a bit of unconsciousness and a broken bit of visor glass. He struggles to his feet, somehow able to breathe - there's air down there which helped to cushion his fall. He sees cave paintings that tell of how the Beast was imprisoned. He finds two urns that glow when he touches them, as depicted on the wall, and then he sees a Balrog chained in front of him. As it makes eye contact with him, Toby starts cackling on the rocket. The Doctor questions the Beast, realising that it won't or can't talk, though it spoke before on the ship. Of course, this is just the body - his mind has escaped upstairs, and its on its way to Earth. Reading the paintings again, The Doctor sees that the pit was designed to destroy the gravity funnel if it was opened, sending the planet (and the Beast) into the black hole, but the concept of the Beast/Satan is just an idea, and if its mind escaped then that idea would escape with it. The Beast's jailors left the air cushion so that someone could make their way down and destroy the Beast before its mind could spread. But destroying the prison would destroy the planet, the gravity funnel and therefore Rose. 

Back in the rocket, Rose is realising that they've gotten away too easily, as the Beast could have stopped them unless it wanted them to escape. Toby, rather uncharacteristically Rose must think, tells her to shut up. The Doctor decides that, whatever he believes in, he believes in Rose, and so he smashes the urns trapping the Beast anyway. As Toby begins to rant and go all Beast-ified again, Rose shots out the window and unlocks his belt so that the mind of the Beast flies into the black hole, followed by the planet, and soon it'll be the rocket. Below, The Doctor runs away from a disintegrating Beast body, only to collide with the TARDIS. As the crew in the rocket accept their fate, they suddenly start to turn around, and then The Doctor's voice speaks to them as he tows them away. He saved Scott too, though he lost all the Ood. 

BIG HUG TIME as The Doctor and Rose are reunited. The crew debate what the TARDIS was exactly, as he tells them that he genuinely doesn't know what the creature was. They all bid their goodbyes, as the TARDIS leaves and the crew fly off...

Aw, crap. I've got to sit through Love and Monsters next time.

As a second part, I think this was an improvement in many ways. You can't always say that Doctor Who second parts improve on the first, but the way the Beast was defeated made sense (the civilisation that trapped it there obviously wouldn't want to destroy their own planet so had to leave it to a future generation), and the performances, though by no means shoddy last week, were raised this time.

The Doctor's face as he reveals that he couldn't save the Ood sums up everything great about David Tennant in the role. It's that haunted expression as he feels the pain of not being able to save someone, despite the fact that there really wasn't anything that he could do about it. I'm guessing it's a fixed point in time, or he could just go back in time and pull them out seconds before. Tennant's whole performance in this episode is great, actually. From his musings on the Beast as he descends into the pit, to his excited cries towards the Beast as he figures out how to destroy it, he's absolutely superb. I feel like he's not in this episode quite as much as normal, too, but the impact he has on it is massive. 

Rose, too, was fantastic as she took on the role of motivator and organiser, when she was trapped with Danny and Jeffersen. In the absence of The Doctor she really stood up, and it shows how far the character has come since the early days of Series 1. Rose's tears and refusal to leave The Doctor are one of Billie Piper's high points of the season. Gods, that woman and character can make the strings pull on my heart!

Of the guest performances, my favourite was Shaun Parkes as Zach, for whom the burden of being Captain weighed heavy on his shoulders throughout, but ultimately stepped up to play his role when it was needed. Claire Rushbrook as Ida Scott was also particularly strong, her interactions with The Doctor around the pit being excellent.

With regards to the characters, talk about a senseless death. Danny tells Jeffersen not to open a door, which he does anyway only for the Ood to then kill someone, exactly as Danny warned. You SUCK as head of security, Jeffersen!

The Beast foreshadows Rose's death, as we often do so see things prophecised in Doctor Who. She will, of course, 'die' in the series finale, so the Beast was partly right, though he's obviously not so powerful that he can't tell the truth behind it (that she was actually just sent to a parallel universe). At this stage, we have no reason to believe any but that the Beast lied, as The Doctor says.
The Bad Wolf theme plays softly in the background as The Doctor tells Scott to tell her...something. Which we all know is that he loves her, right? Of course it is. I'm trying to decide if I mind the whole 'Doctor in love with companion' thing or not, and really I think I'm fine with it. I think it's logical. The Doctor has found someone that makes him happy again after all the crap of the Time War, so why wouldn't he fall in love? His role as the Ninth Doctor was of someone introducing Rose to the universe, but now she's more of an equal. 

I do have a quibble with some of the science: so Rose shoots out the window of the rocket, letting the cold vacuum of space straight in, but none of them suffer at all? Did I miss something there?! Surely I missed something!

Torchwood Mentions
The expedition represents the Torchwood Archive

Overall
An improvement on part one, with a particularly strong performance from David Tennant as he destroys the Beast to save Rose and the crew. 

8/10

Revisiting Doctor Who – Series 2, Episode 8 – The Impossible Planet

Revisiting Doctor Who – Series 2, Episode 8 – The Impossible Planet

The TARDIS materialises on a deep space exploratory ‘sanctuary base’, The Doctor and Rose popping out of it. Its walls have strange symbols daubed on them, untranslatable by the TARDIS, making it very old. And it also has ‘Welcome to Hell’ written above in English, which is sort of comforting that at least we can read part of it. When they try to leave the room, they open the door to find a bunch of what we’ll soon learn are Ood, empathic servants, declaring that they ‘must feed’, and it kinda looks like The Doctor and Rose are the meal...
Cue title sequence...

Oh, wait, it’s just a dodgy vocal box that the Ood is carrying – one good smack and it changes to ‘we must feed...you, if you are hungry’. Phew! Officers soon burst in, surprised to see The Doctor and Rose. One quake alert later, they end up in the control room, to find more surprised crew. When that’s all over, they learn they’re on a planet with no air, and that one of the storage areas has been destroyed, which a bloke called Toby goes off to investigate. After being introduced to the rest of the crew, we learn that the base is on a planet in orbit of a black hole, which is impossible. The Doctor is like, ‘SERIOUSLY, WTF?’. Toby, meanwhile, is hearing voices as he heads around the base.

According to some scriptures, the planet is called Krop Tor, and the black hole is a might demon who was trapped into devouring itself, only to spit it out because it was poison. ‘The Bitter Pill’, is its translation. A gravity funnel shoots out of the black hole, which the crew used to travel down. The crew are drilling down to find the power source, which in no way is going to cause a bloody big problem. The writing on the wall was copied from fragments by Toby, and they’re hoping to find more. The Doctor praises them for their wish to explore, whilst telling them that they’re utterly mad and need to flee. However, Rose and he won’t be fleeing any time soon, as it was Storage Bays 5-8 that collapsed, and the TARDIS was parked in 6...

Whilst The Doctor and Rose contemplate a life without time travel, Toby is analysing fragments and hearing voices again. At the same time, as Rose is chatting to an Ood serving her meal, it politely informs her that ’The Beast and his armies shall rise from the pit, to make war against God’, which one an odd response to her non-Beast related question. She assumes it be a glitch, but behind Captain Zach the 3d display of the planet briefly changes to a shot of a horned Balrog snarling, but changes back before he can properly see what has just happened. The computer system tells Danny that ‘he’s awake’ as he opens a door. Toby then finds the symbols drawn on his hands following a voice warning him not to turn around or else he will die, which he promptly does anyway Then he sees his face in a mirror, which is covered with symbols, and new bright red eyes. He then collapses.

The rest of the crew watch a solar system burning up in the black hole. Rose gets a call on a phone with no signal, also informing her that ‘he is awake’. Toby’s eyes spring open at this point. Could be connected? The Doctor and Rose question Danny about the Ood, and their telepathy. The Oods biosigns suddenly go from Basic 5 to Basic 30, which apparently means that something is shouting at them in their heads. Apparently, according to the Ood, we should worship whatever is awake. Toby, meanwhile, has gone outside without a spacesuit, so I think he’s kind of not Toby anymore. Boy does he have a freaky maniacal expression on his face. He also cracks the glass from a distance, sucking Scooti out to the planet’s surface, and compromising the base’s integrity.

Everyone, including Toby, makes it further inside the base, but they’ve lost Section 11-13. Somehow Scooti is apparently in Habitation 3, despite being a bit dead. When the crew get there, they find her stuck to the glass dome, outside. She floats off to the black hole after a short minute. At the same time, the massive drill stops. They’ve reached Point Zero, the goal of the drill. The Doctor volunteers to go with Scott, down to its lowest depths. Despite Danny’s warnings to only obey him, the Ood all stand as one when the capsule reaches the bottom of the shaft.

The Doctor and Scott step out into a massive cavern, complete with carvings and massive statues, remnants of a past civilisation. The Ood’s eyes change to red, as their biosigns change to Basic 100, putting the crew on alert, as The Doctor and Scott find a massive metal seal, covered in symbols. Questioning Toby on what the symbols mean, everyone is a little surprised when Toby stands up and they see his face is covered in symbols again, his eyes are red, and his voice has broken. He tells them that the symbols are ‘the words of the Beast...and he has woken’. With a strange cry, the symbols fly of his face and onto the Ood, turning them into the Legion of the Beast. Turns out the Beast is Satan, of course, and his Legion have the ability to electrocute people in the head using their translation sphere, which they do to some bloke who I swear has only just appeared on the crew roster. The seal begins to open, and the planet starts to move as the gravity field collapses. The Beast/Legion continue to rant about being free, as The Doctor and Scott look warily down into the pit...

It’s rather an ingenious idea, using the idea of Satan as the basis for an episode. In many societies there seems to be an evil force that people believe in, so why wouldn’t there be an actual beast from the beginning of time that was the starting point for the legend? This doesn’t confirm the existence of God at all, just that there are some nasty beasts out there.

It’s a pretty scary episode for children, what with the symbols written over Toby and the Ood turning evil. I know that, even in future episodes featuring them, I still get a bit wary of the Ood suddenly turning again. They’re definitely one of new-Who’s most memorable aliens.

The episode itself has plenty of intriguing points to it, from the impossible nature of the planet’s orbit around the black hole, the concept of the beast being Satan, and the issues surround slavery. Regarding the latter, Rose is rightly appalled by the thought of humanity once again resorting to taking slaves, even though the humans in the future don’t see it as a problem because the Ood actively want to serve. A similar dilemma has been raised about humanity building robots who want to serve in the present; does that make it alright? After all, that’s kind of how The Matrix started.

The episode itself sets up the second half nicely, because in all honesty, how the hell is The Doctor expected to slay Satan? Overall, it’s a solid episode that brings the ideas mentioned above together nicely, but it lacks a lot of the fun interactions between Rose and The Doctor that I like so much. I know that it’s a much darker episode, but others have managed to be very dark yet very funny in places, and I just don’t see that as much here. Also, the recovery of the TARDIS just seems to disappear from The Doctor and Rose’s plans pretty quickly. I know the captain has said that they can’t divert the drill to go and look for it, but I can’t imagine The Doctor giving up that easily.

The Doctor’s love for humans comes out in a hug for Acting Captain Zach, who looks sheepishly pleased by it all. We’re amazing, apparently, with the way we love to explore and discover what’s out there, even though it inevitably leads to a shedload of problems that The Doctor has to rescue us from. Tennant’s glee whenever The Doctor gets excited has always been one of his most memorable traits, and it never fails to raise a smile when it crops up.

The Doctor’s role as the Last of the Time Lords come to the forefront again with his insistence on finding the TARDIS because ‘It’s all I’ve got, literally the only thing’. In this minute, he’s not thinking about Rose. His guilt at the thought of trapping Rose is brought out, as well, when he thinks they can’t go anywhere. It’s meant to be fun, this universe travelling, not dangerous!

There an awkward love moment when The Doctor and Rose are talking about the possibility of not travelling the universe anymore, having to settle down, and potentially doing so together. Oh, how those flames of love are being fanned! She even kisses his space helmet (that’s not an innuendo).

Perhaps one of Who’s best jokes that only UK viewers will understand is when Scott says that there’s no going back, a sure sign in horror films that things are going to go wrong, to which The Doctor replies that saying that is almost as bad as ‘this is going to be the best Christmas Walford’s ever had’. Made me laugh a lot, that one.

A TARDIS is grown, not built. Just another fun fact about Time Lords.

Torchwood Mentions
None

Overall
A solid episode that leads in nicely to the second part, but without a lot of the warmth and humour that has made new-Who so special for me.
7/10


Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 6 Review

Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 6 Review

*This review contains spoilers*


With the finale of Line of Duty Series 2 comes the end of yet another TV show I wished that I had known about at the time it was first broadcast. Over the past six episodes, we've seen twist and turn, guilt and innocence, drama and heartbreak, right until the very end. Is it a satisfying ending? Very much so, even though it's one that I expect has probably polarised opinion.

In the end, it turns out that yes, DI Lynsey Denton was guilty. Except she wasn't, sort of. She was, technically, but not morally. And even technically, she was only sort of.

Basically, Denton was approached by DS Akers, after she had seen Alex Lawrence (Tommy Hunter was Series 1 in his Witness Protection guise) beating up Carly Kirk, who had just been kicked out of DCC Dryden's car when he realised that Denton had seen the two of them together (still following?). Akers wants to give Hunter over to other underground bad guys, to stop him being able to harm girls like Carly (as he has been granted immunity, he apparently cannot be convicted of any crimes), and wants Denton to help do this, giving her a wad of cash. It turns out that DI Cottan is also in on this (we know he is The Caddy from previous episodes). On the night of the ambush, Denton changes her mind and goes off on a different route, only for the assassins (Prassad and Cole) to find them anyway, due to a tracker planted on her car, which she finds and switches on to the car carrying Akers, Hunter and the two (innocent) police officers.

That's it basically, if you can follow that rather garbled explanation. Why did Denton change her mind last minute? Presumably with an attack of conscience (though Hunter was an evil shit who liked beating kids, Denton is still a professional, and was still sending him to death and torture). Dryden, therefore, is innocent of any involvement in the conspiracy, and Cottan ordered the hits on the other officers and Akers to eliminate anyone who knew of his involvement - Hunter is dead, which was the end goal, and Denton was spared as she didn't know of his involvement, and there was also someone for him to focus the investigation on. 

It's fairly watertight, though I still think that Dryden's manner in offering a promotion to Supt Hastings in the previous episode was too much of a red herring, as he wouldn't have acted so shiftily if he didn't have any involvement. Still, that's a fairly minor quibble. The real story is that, according to the end of episode notes, Denton pleaded not guilty to conspiracy to murder, but was found guilty by a majority. The evidence all points to her, of course (nicely done, Cottan), but it's still a tragedy as this is someone who ultimately trying to save young girls from a monster. All done in the wrong manner, of course, and it led to the death of four police officers (including Georgia from Episode 1), but her only involvement in a conspiracy was to hand Hunter over to other criminals, which was all he deserved. No one ever said that Line of Duty was trying to make a pleasant drama. 

Throughout all of this, the acting has been superb. Keeley Hawes morally ambiguous Denton has helped keep us guessing right until the very end, with an incredible range of extremes in her performance, from the almost psychopathic attack on her neighbour, to the despair at her mother's death. Vicky McClure as DC Fleming and Martin Compston as DS Arnott have been the two rocks holding the investigation together, fighting their own demons as they go along, particularly Fleming with the breakdown of her marriage and having to live in her car. Supt Hastings, played by Adrian Dunbar, is rightly earning many plaudits as the officer who is desperate to advance in his career to help save his marriage and financial woes, but knows that doing the right thing will scupper all those. Mark Bonnar as DCC Dryden was particularly brilliant in the interview of Episode 5, going from the cold man in charge, to the wreck at the end as he sees his world crashing down around him. I can't emphasise just how much I like Craig Parkinson in anything, but he's wonderful as DI Cottan, who is surely going to keep getting away with things with each progressive season until it all crumbles down at the very end.

The individual moments of this episode probably don't matter compared with the ending that closes the story, but there were some definite highlights. Watching Fleming hammer on her front door when she learns her husband has changed the locks (something that normally happens to the man) is heartbreaking, when you realise just what a disrupted home life she's been hiding. Arnott's reveal that he's been playing Denton (though how far back we don't know) is also top notch, helping to reconcile the two work colleagues who appeared to have been drifting apart. Hastings telling Dryden that he would throw the book at him, as other charges around him are dropped, tops off Hasting's character arc for the series perfectly.

Standing above them, though, it couldn't really be anything but the grand reveal of the truth. The flashback in Denton's head, and in particular the brutal nature of Carly Kirk's kidnapping, are what we've wanted to know about all along, and the knowledge that Denton is ultimately innocent finally puts our minds at rest. If we were in her position, given the chance to rid the world of a scumbag who targets teenage girls, wouldn't we try to do something? There's a lot to sympathise with her about it, and it's clear why she felt she couldn't come forward - Hunter is dead, which was the ultimate goal, and if she could have held out a bit longer without the money she was paid being found, there was no evidence to put her away.

Line of Duty has been utterly superb, right from the beginning. I'm desperate to catch Series 1 now (hurry up and return it please, library folk), and desperate to catch Series 3 as soon as it airs. I've not been this impressed by a UK drama since Spooks (discounting Doctor Who), and with Prey impressing equally on ITV at the moment, it's a very strong time for UK television.

Roll on, Series 3!

Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 5 Review

Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 5

*This review contains spoilers*

I swear, if Line of Duty gets any better, it'll be criminal (ahem).

This week, we see the walls come toppling down on the conspiracy in a huge way. DCC Dryden's involvement becomes plain, as he is arrested and charged with a whole host of offences, including murder and conspiracy to murder. At the moment, the order of business is looking like this:
  • Dryden had sexual relations with 15 year old Carly Kirk, which was caught on camera by key witness Tommy Hunter
  • When learning about Hunter wanting to bribe him, Dryden had PC Prassad and PC Cole murder her to keep her from talking, and also set up the ambush that killed Hunter
It all looks fairly clear at this point, were it not for the last minute reveal of an abortion by DI Denton earlier in year, and the hint of a smile on her face as she watched the news broadcast about Dryden's arrest. All of a sudden, it looks as though perhaps the ambush was set up by Denton after all, to incriminate Dryden as revenge for making her go through with an abortion and not leaving his wife.

Gods, I don't know who to trust any more.

The interview scene where Dryden is charged is absolutely superb. Watching Dryden go from cold, hard and in control to utterly deflated is mesmerising, as are the performances of Martin Compston as DS Arnott and Vicky McClure as DC Fleming, who go the opposite way from nervous at interviewing their commanding officer, to full-on bad cop at its termination. If anything, it tops the interview that Arnott, Fleming and Supt Hastings gave Denton in Episode 2.

Before we get to Denton's pleased expression whilst watching the television, there is one further hint that perhaps everything still doesn't quite add up. As Hastings points out, the photos incriminating Dryden were found on the car-computer of Prassad; surely that would make Prassad part of the conspiracy to blackmail Dryden, rather than suddenly turn around and help him. Just another small piece that means we're so close yet so far from the truth.

All the performances are top-notch, as ever. Performance of the week has to go to Mark Bonnar as Dryden, for that incredible switch of character in the interview room. Hastings conflict between doing the right thing and getting on with his career are brilliant as well. I don't have too much sympathy for him in one respect, because in no way should he allow his career to get in the way of justice for a murdered teenager and four police officers, but at the same time you can understand how difficult it must be to arrest someone so high up in the force. The scene between the two of them, where Hastings begins to outline that he thinks there may be more involved in the conspiracy and is clearly accusing Dryden, is brilliant, especially the way that Dryden all but confesses when he suggests Hastings might get a promotion if he wants it. If that's not a way of saying 'yeah, I did it, but if you drop it then it'll be worth it' then I don't know what is. In fact, if Dryden turns out not to have done it, I think that's one of the only ways we could call fault with the storyline; that scene would be a deliberate red herring, but an unfair one.

There are other little storylines knocking about, such as DI Cottan's slightly-corrupt cop (which ties into Series 1 and I've still not had a chance to watch), Fleming apparently being yet another officer who owes a lot of money (seriously, are the police that badly paid?) and Arnott letting himself down by not sleeping with someone for two weeks running, All in all, anticipation for the finale couldn't be higher.

Saturday, 10 May 2014

Revisiting Doctor Who - Series 2, Episode 7 - The Idiot's Lantern

Revisiting Doctor Who – Series 2, Episode 7 – The Idiot’s Lantern

England. Sometime after WWII. Mr Magpie looks over his accounts, needing a miracle, whilst another family read, listen to the radio and freak out their grandchildren about brains melting. A typical evening in a 50s British household in other words. A bolt of red lightning hits the aerial of Mr Magpie’s shop, turning the TV back on, but it’s all rather strange when the lady on the TV starts talking directly to him. Now, are you sitting comfortably? Good! Then we’ll begin…sucking his face into the TV with red lightning, apparently.

Cue title sequence…

The Doctor and Rose are dressed ready for 50s America, to go see Elvis on the Ed Sullivan Show, so they’re a bit disappointed when it turns out to be 1953 London, all set for Elizabeth II’s coronation. The family with the melting brains are enjoying having a TV, though apparently the gran now has an awful face, and is knocking on the floor from upstairs, which I imagine is in no way connected to the face sucking red lightning thing. Turns out that, unlike everywhere else, everyone round here has a TV, as Magpie’s shop sells them for £5 a pop. It’s in old money but still, that’s like…not much.

Suddenly, a man is taken away in a car with a blanket over his head, which Tommy from the originally family says is happening plenty, with everyone turning into monsters. The Doctor and Rose pursue on their scooter, but the supposed police officers have initiated ‘Operation Market Stall’, which involves blocking the road with a market stall, and disappeared behind some big doors, unbeknownst to our heroes.

In his shop, Mr Magpie has finished something electronic, which pleases the television lady. Apparently she’s burning him behind his eyes, which is just plain mean. She’s a bit condescending too. I don’t like her. Too smiley. Never trust someone who smiles that much. It betrays hidden turmoil. Never go up and investigating a strange banging grandmother, either, which is a lesson Tommy should learn when he tries to do just that, before his father can stop him. Rose and The Doctor call on them, taking delight in getting Mr Connolly to do some housework, before Mrs Connolly begs for help with her mother. Piping Mr Connolly’s ego down, The Doctor hears of how people seem to be changing everywhere, before getting taken away by the police. Investigating the grandma, we see that she basically has no face now. It’s like it’s been wiped clean, or a blank canvas. The police/men in black turn up before they can do anything else, punching out The Doctor as they go. He heads off on his scooter to follow them, but Rose has become distracted by red lightning buzzing around the TV, and she sees the name ‘Magpie Electricals’ on the back of it before leaving.

The Doctor realises what’s happening with Operation Market Garden, finding a back way in, and finding a lot of people without faces locked up in a pen together. They react to him by clenching their fists and heading towards him, before a huge spotlight shines on him, and he warned to stay where he is. Meanwhile, in Magpie’s Electricals, Rose questions the owner on why his prices are so low, before the strange TV lady appears crying about being hungry. When Rose tells him that she knows the televisions are behind it, the lady reveals herself as ‘The Wire’, sucking Rose’s face off. Turns out her plan is to feed on the 20 million people watching the coronation.

The Doctor is being questioned by Detective Inspector Bishop, though he points out that the police aren’t really doing much detective inspecting. Turns out that faces being sucked off is a bit beyond what the police normally deal with, so The Doctor offers to lend a hand. He’s a bit downbeat though when the police bring Rose in. Very determined, though. He’s going to kick some ass.

The family are watching the coronation, with some thinly veiled threats from Mr Connolly towards his wife and Tommy (who has been goading him by suggesting relatives go upstairs to visit his gran), when The Doctor shows up. Mr Connolly tries to take control of the situation, but Tommy tells his father what a massive bellend fascist he’s being, as it was his father who informed on everyone in the street. Mrs Connolly also tells him to sod off, before going back to watch the coronation. Tommy goes with The Doctor and DI Bishop, heading to Magpie Electricals, where they discover the electrical thing Magpie made. When the sonic screwdriver is activated, it turns all the TVs on, and we see that everyone whose face has been sucked off is stuck inside one of them. So, Rose is alive! Woo! When Magpie appears, The Doctor gets all shouty again, but The Wire makes herself known, turning into a colour image and declaring that by feasting on everyone she will gain a corporeal body, which her own kind denied her. Turns out they executed her, but she fled in this form across the stars. The portable television that Magpie built is designed to transport her to a bigger transmitter, as she can’t do it all without. She starts to feed off them, but The Doctor stops it with the threat of the sonic screwdriver. Whilst The Doctor recovers on the floor, The Wire transmits to the portable TV and gets Magpie to drive her to a much bigger transmitter.

The Doctor rouses Tommy (DI Bishop has lost his face), figuring out that The Wire is headed for Alexandra Palace, the biggest transmitter in the area. They bring a load of electronics with them, as we see Magpie head up the tower with the portable TV. Tommy looks after the electronics in a room whilst The Doctor heads up the transmitter after Magpie and The Wire carrying, well, a wire. Red lightning starts to crackle all around as Magpie connects the portable television, and 20 million people begin to have their faces sucked off. The Wire chats bollocks for a while, Magpie moans and then gets disintegrated by The Wire, and The Doctor eventually saves the day when Tommy replaces a faulty electrical thingy in the big electrical thingy box, and he’s able to do something electrical to stop it. I don’t know much about electrics and electricals, but it turned the receiver back into a transmitter and he trapped The Wire in a VHS.

Back with the police, Tommy is reunited with his gran and The Doctor with Rose. Mrs Connolly kicks out Mr Connolly, and everyone else celebrates with a street party. After a pep talk from Rose, Tommy heads off to try and turn his Dad into a decent chap, as she and the Doctor share a glass of orange.

Now, all we need is for The Doctor to get rid of his scary 50s haircut, and all will be right with the world

I’ve seen this episode feature quite low on Who-fans lists before, and I think that’s a little unfair. It’s not a spectacular episode by any means, and it certainly isn’t going to make it onto any ‘best of’ lists, but it’s not a bad episode at all. Perhaps that’s the problem then; there’s just nothing that makes it stand out as being particularly brilliant. Certainly, if you asked me to name all the episodes of Series 2, this is one of the ones I’d be likely to forget.

It’s full of strong performances, as ever. Billie Piper in particular is fantastic when she puts on her commanding voice to school Mr Connolly about being British. I’ve got to say, Mr Connolly is a massive dick, but there isn’t a single role that the actor, Jamie Foreman,  plays where he doesn’t make it better because he’s so accomplished a playing a massive dick. Boy, do I hate his character in basically every role. He also does bully-turned-simpering-idiot very well, too.

Debra Gillett as Rita Connolly is perfect. The show could have run away with her finally getting rid of Mr Connolly, changing her instantly from a meek and mild mannered lady to a ferocious woman-scorned with a temper to put her husband in the dark, as is what usually happens in these circumstances; instead, she quietly tells him to get out, and calmly tells everyone it’s a new beginning (along those lines). It’s a wonderful change, and brilliantly played. You fully believe that she’s just so relieved and happy her tyrant husband is gone, and she’s looking forward to the future now. Rory Jennings as Tommy Connolly is also very good, convincing as the child who just wants to help solve the situation and find out what’s happening to his gran, whilst living under the harsh rule of his father.

Speaking of women in these times - yes, these jokes have been done to death in every form by now, but watching The Doctor force the bullying Mr Connolly to do ‘a woman’s job’ is still funny (‘Does the Queen do the housework?’). Especially so when Rose corrects him on his Union Jack vs Union Flag error. Which, of course, I wouldn’t have made.
The Doctor’s temper comes out in full force when Mr Connolly tries to take back control of his house. As a complete aside, I laughed with the way he said ‘I’m not listening-AH!, as it reminded me of Metallica’s James Hetfield, or WWE’s HHH. He’s quite angry throughout, really, especially when Rose loses her face.

The Wire is a creepy baddie, but Christ do I find her ‘hungry’ and ‘feed me’ cries annoying! Almost-enough-to-knock-a-ratings-point-off annoying. MEGA-annoying. Fantastic actress and performance all round though. Reminds me exactly of the type of presenter I’ve seen in classic BBC shows.

I laughed like a drain at ‘Operation Market Stall’ being nothing more than putting out a market stall. Brilliant!

If there’s one other thing, besides the ‘feed me’ annoyance, that I didn’t like about the episode, it’s David Tennant’s hairstyle. Christ, there’s some volume in there! I just think it looks terrible, and thank the gods it seems to have gone back to normal in next week’s episode. I was distracted by it all the way through!

Torchwood Mentions
Mentioned by a police officer

Overall
Nothing spectacular, but nothing too shabby either. Just a fairly run-of-the-mill episode at the end of the day.
7/10


Thursday, 8 May 2014

Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 4 Review

Line of Duty Series 2 Episode 4 Review

*This review contains spoilers*

I'm not really able to articulate just how good Episode 4 of Line of Duty Series 2 is. It's full of revelation after revelation throughout, with parts of the conspiracy starting to slot nicely into place, yet still leaving us feeling far away from knowing the full truth about what's going on.

For Denton, there's no denying that we're now being formally placed in the 'believe her to be innocent' pile. She at least receives what appear to be more lawful-good guards, has a visit to her dying mother, and is then kidnapped by two crooked members of the police when they ram the van she is being escorted in off the road.

Of those two officers, one is identified by Carly Kirk's parents as being a Detective who came and took away evidence from her bedroom and possessions, something which Fleming explains wouldn't be done in the way it was, immediately letting us know something was up. He happens to also be Carly's boyfriend. Said boyfriend was seen talking to Dryden at a dinner event, which Carly was also working, which happens to be on the night that Dryden apparently took the blame for a speeding fine in place of his wife, which gives him an alibi for the night Carly disappeared...and the second officer is the hitman who murdered Georgia in Episode 1. It's pretty clear now that Dryden is behind a lot of this, though there are still plenty of pieces of the jigsaw to slot in place.

One of the best scenes of the series takes place early on, as Fleming, Arnott and Cottan convince Hastings to let them bring in Dryden about the traffic violation, whilst also hoping to probe into his alleged relationship with Denton. It's a wonderfully hostile performance by Mark Bonnar as Dryden, who could easily be either a master villain or just a high-ranking officer who's pissed off at being brought in for questioning. His denial of having had previous contact with Denton is thrown out of the window later on with the exposure of phone records connecting the two, plus staff at a hotel they used to meet remembering them. Hastings reaction to the whole affair, too, is superb, with his conflict between his future career prospects and doing the right thing leading him to try and put off the inevitable. With the amount of evidence that will be brought to him at the start of the next episode, though, he'll have no choice but to allow further questioning.

Fleming's moral guilt comes into play, too, as she ends up in tears in a toilet cubicle over being incorrect about Denton's involvement. Someone else with guilt on their mind, though probably more fearing for their illegal activities from Series 1 (so I believe) coming to light than anything else, is Cottan; recordings that DS Akers made before her murder show the key witness talking about corruption in the police threatening the immunity he has been promised. He talks about 'the two-faced bastard' (or some such description), which another video shows to be Dryden, talking about never granting immunity. He also mentions another officer further down the chain of command, which the expression on Cottan's face can only indicate refers to himself. Naturally, he offers to follow up this detail himself, so the likelihood at this stage is he'll weasel his way out of it, which will mean more Craig Parkinson for Series 3, and therefore this is a very good thing indeed.

Denton's visit to her mother is emotionally traumatic, as you'd expect from someone in her position, and there's conflict within her when her guards fall asleep and she has the chance to escape out of the front door. It's more evidence for her innocence that she doesn't, though following her capture at the end she probably regrets not having made a run for it.

All in all, this was the best episode of Series 2 yet, with all the pieces moving together nicely. There's only two episodes to go, so we'll soon have the full truth with plenty more twists along the way. It's fantastic television, this, and even pausing to write this review is leaving me impatient to get on watching the next episode. UK TV dramas don't get much better than this.